What is beauty?
A medieval "definition"
of beauty that I recall from my days in philosophy is "pluchra sunt
quae visa placent." "Things are beautiful when seeing them gives
pleasure."
This has never satisfied me. First
of all, it is not a definition. It does not say what beauty IS. It describes
what happens when one sees a beautiful thing. And second, it limits itself to
the sense of sight. Things we hear can be beautiful, as well as things we touch
or smell or even taste (though we don't usually describe tasted things as
beautiful).
So what IS beauty?
Beauty is something that is in an
object outside oneself. We say "beauty is in the eye of the
beholder." Well, not exactly. We perceive beauty as something coming from
outside ourselves. Beauty is not produced by oneself, it is given.
So the first piece of a definition
of beauty is that beauty is a gift.
I like this. Beauty is a gift. When
I see a beautiful sunset, or a beautiful sculpture, I am receiving a gift. A
gift implies a giver. Who gives sunsets? God. The existence of beauty may be
the most satisfactory "proof" for the existence of God in our day.
Beauty is a gift experienced
through human senses. When I say human, I not only say that there is a giver,
but that there is a receiver. If there were no humans, would there be beauty?
But lots of things are experienced
through human senses, and not all of them are beautiful. What makes a beautiful
experience beautiful?
Hormones. Something happens to my
hormones when I experience something beautiful. The medieval definition uses
the word placent. It give pleasure. Pleasure is a hormonal thing. I
don't know enough about hormones to say which hormones are operating--I let
that up to the biologists. I just know that there are hormones involved, and
that the hormones give delight.
So, my definition: beauty is a
delight-producing gift to human senses.
We
spend money on beauty.
I drive along Interstate 88
approaching Chicago. I pass remarkable buildings, obviously designed by
professional architects, and the buildings are surrounded by professionally
designed landscapes. Corporations spend millions to make their headquarters look
beautiful, Why? They want people to perceive the corporation as a giver of
beauty. If the corporation gives beauty, people will assume it will also give
other good things.
Look at what people spend on the
architecture of their homes. I drive through wealthy neighborhoods and marvel
at how important the people living there must think beauty is. Then I wonder
how often the people living in those homes are able to enjoy the beauty. They
might be working 16 hours a day and never come home in the daylight. They might
be undergoing a divorce, and cannot see the beauty because of the pain they are
suffering internally.
I drive through poor neighborhoods
and am sad because beauty is so often absent. Things are ugly, the opposite of
beautiful.
Though not always. Some years ago
two photographers went around Quincy, where I live, and took pictures of tiny
pieces of beauty, especially in architecture: a cornice on a building, the
brickwork on a chimney. One that sticks in my mind is a picture of a garbage
can placed in a carefully sculpted niche in a building. Someone made the
garbage can's location into a gift that could cause delight.
When I was interviewing people in
Chicago for my dissertation, I sometimes went into one of the
"projects," the terrible high-rises designed by misguided city
planners back in the 1950s and 60s. In spite of the disastrous public spaces
(urine-smelling elevators that quit working, leaving people to climb 16 flights
of stairs to their apartments), the people living in those places often
succeeded in making their private spaces beautiful. They were not in control of
the public spaces, but where they could make beauty, they made it.
I once toured Hannibal with a
restorationist, a man whose profession was to restore beauty to old buildings.
He kept pointing out houses and saying, "Look at what a gift that house is
to the street!" A gift.
Every hospital I have visited in
recent years has been a marvel of
architectural development. The hospital started out years ago with a modest
building, and each addition became more elaborate and beautiful. Corridors and
private rooms are hung with art work. Perhaps it helps us to deal with the
tragedies of illness when we are surrounded with beauty.
Beauty is God's gift to us as
humans. By helping to make the world more beautiful, we come closer to God.
Joe, I appreciated your comments on beauty ... and a question, if beauty is a gift (akin the Genesis announcements that the activities of that day of creative activity were "good")doesn't that make the recipient of the gift the judge of whether or not it was really "good"?
ReplyDeleteI am awestruck by the beauty and by the the harshness of the world around us. And far short of the entire cosmos, elements of what some admire in music strike me as ugly, and certainly a great deal of what seems to get applause in our economy strikes me as far removed from "beauty".
Shalom
Clyde